Diablo Canyon Decommissioning Engagement Panel

Public Comments

DateDecommissioning TopicComment / Suggestion:Group Affiliation, if any (Optional)Link to Web Page or Online FileUploaded File 1Uploaded File 2
August 28, 2018Lands

"Wildness" is the word that comes to mind when I think of the Pecho Coast and Diablo Lands. Decisions made on the future of these lands are critical to keep the wildness in this place. We should consider the lands "highest value" . . .the value it possesses in its own right, for what it is. I believe these lands highest value is that it offers people, from all walks of life, opportunities to enjoy nature - for renewal, discovery, and learning.

I believe that the land should not be used for intensive recreational use. Opening it to the masses would be its downfall, as we have loved too many places to death. In California, the rawness and spectacular beauty of this coastline and coastal bluffs is a rarity - in that it has been relatively untouched by humans. Wide open access would create unwanted trails down to beaches causing erosion. Harbor seal and sea otter haul-out sites would be disturbed, and the sensitive intertidal animals would be disturbed and diminished. PG&E has recognized that access must be managed to protect and preserve the resources and character of the land.

Continuing PG&E's land stewardship program of managed public access that has kept this place so special requires foresight, understanding, and creative effort. A collaborative effort with Land Conservancies, Land Trusts, Range Trusts, Cal Poly research, and other non-profits that foster understanding and respect for nature, and show care and commitment to the lands future may just keep the Pecho Coast unspoiled for future generations - a place where wildness still reigns.

August 28, 2018Lands

Please allow as much public access as possible on these lands, especially for equestrian and hiking use, and especially in the Wild Cherry Canyon. The SLO coast is remarkable and rare, please permit it to be it open for everyone.

Ride Nipomo
August 28, 2018Lands

All the open land should be kept as open space with trails accessible to the public, ideally as an extension of the Montana de Oro park and in the same vein. Low impact camping would be ok in one area but not concessions or more roads. Bathrooms would be good.

August 27, 2018Lands

Please save this precious piece of the coast for public use, including Multi-use trails for equestrians, biking and hiking. Thank you!

Ride Nipomo
August 27, 2018Lands

Please consider use for public open space and multi-use trails, especially equestrian trails with access to MdO

all local equestrian groups
August 27, 2018Lands

Please separate horse and bike trails from human walking trails, if included in public access. They have destructive, trail-degrading means of locomotion, PLUS both represent a danger to human hikers. I don't view either as being amenable to sharing right of way safely, as BOTH demand right of way over human hikers on foot, and yet are far more dangerous. I worry also about horse manure bringing in non-native, invasive species to these isolated wild lands. It happens everywhere.

member local Audubon chapter
August 27, 2018Lands

Dear Diablo Canyon Decommissioning Engagement Panel,

I understand that on Wednesday, August 29, 2018, you will be taking public comment on the future use of the Diablo Canyon Power Plant (DCPP) once it is decommissioned. Unfortunately, I cannot make the evening meeting so please accept my thoughts and comments below.

The DCPP and the surrounding lands are nothing short of spectacular. They are home to a multidude of marine mammals, chumash archaeological sites and burial grounds, unique geologic features, rare plants, wetlands, pocket beaches, a historic lighthouse, and so much more. This moment, when you are deciding on the future of the DCPP lands, brings to mind the words of Mardie Murie, a renowned scientist and conservationist, who said, when she was advocating for the protection of Alaskan wildlands, " Alaska must be allowed to be Alaska, that is her greatest economy. I hope the United States of America is not so rich that she can afford to let these wildernesses pass by, or so poor she cannot afford to keep them." The same can be said of the DCPP lands. Please do not squander this one and only opportunity to conserve a unique and ecologically valuable stretch of the central coast. The highest and best use of the DCPP lands are to leave them in their natural state. To do so will be such a positive reflection of the values of our community and our high regard for nature. If we do otherwise, the lands and the tremendous values they hold will be gone forever.

I urge you in the strongest terms possible to conserve the 12,000 acres of DCPP when the power plant is decommissioned.

August 27, 2018Lands

Comments dated August 27, 2018 for the SLO County Supervisor Meeting on August 29, 2018 By Simone Malboeuf, Los Osos, CA 93402

Dear PGE Engagement Panel: Thanks for providing this online alternative for leaving public comment, so I don't have to wait in line at the SLO Sups meeting to be told after hours of waiting that time is up and no more comments will be taken. Here are my comments: In January 2017, the CPuC released a new wildfire threat map that outlines areas in the state at an elevated or extreme risk from utility associated wildfires. This map was created usint utility datea from power companies around the state and fire danger information from CalFire and the California State Department of Forestry. The new rules require increased vegetation management in higher risk areas. Each electric investor owned utility will have to file an annual report that has a wildfire fire-prevention/protection plan. Has PG&E filed their plan yet? And what is that plan - how can the public acquire a copy of it? eatall the horrendous wild fires in 2017 and the incredibly destructive California wildfires still burning out of control - SLO county residents need to know there is a plan in place should an uncontrollable wildfire take place in SLO county - which could threaten the homes and lives of its residents. How can I get a copy of the CalFire required wildfire protection plan for DCNPP? How can the residents of SLO county be assured that every precaution is being taken to secure their safety from an unpredictable Wild Fire threat to Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant and subsequent consequences to the public? The CPUC's new Wildfire Threat Map shows large areas of Diablo Canyon and Big Sur areas north of San Luis Obispo, to be in the High to Highest portential Wildfire danger areas. What precautions has PG&E already taken since receiving this information last year? Since the Santa Barbara fires last year, I don't believe anyone in SLO county feels their property should be considered Not at risk - as Cal Fire does not, by its Wildfire Threat map.
In 2017, at one of the many Diablo Canyon Independent Safety Committee meetings, Dr. Budnitz gave a compelling speech, captured on video, about how he personally was NOT convinced that the personnel issues surrounding the closure of Diablo Canyon NPP (the early departure of the most qualified NPP employees would be the first to leave and secure employment elsewhere leaving the operation of the plant to less qualified, less experienced and less knowledgeable employees ) would leave the DCNPP operating safely in the years between now and when it turns off its nuclear reactor for good. You can find that video on the Mothers for Peace website, mothersforpeace.org. In a nutshell,Dr. Budnitz state he did not believe PGE would have the proper staff needed left to run the plant safely - in spite of their intentions to do so. Another argument for shutting it down sooner then later. (3.5 minute video)
In regards to opening land around the DCNPP for development - residential homes, open space for recreational use or whatever. Please consider this information from Dave Lochbaum of the Union of Concerned Scientists in his email to me on the subject: February 5, 2018

Hello Simone:

Your point about wild fires is a good one.

An early step in the decommissioning process is to conduct thorough surveys of the hazardous materials, both within buildings and in soils around them.

The surveys are intended to confirm the location and quantity of hazardous materials (both radioactive and toxic) so as to enable informed decisions about how to dismantle the facility.

In the past, wild fires have re-released radioactivity "trapped" in vegetation. For example, circa 1999 or 2000, wild fires near the Los Alamos National Laboratory in New Mexico caused detectable levels of radiation in the air/smoke. While initially indicative of a current release from Los Alamos, the radiation was attributed to re-release of radiation released over the years as the fire burned shrubbery and trees that had absorbed the radiation in roots.

Thus, wild fires might directly challenge safety at Diablo Canyon and could cause a re-release of radiation. The detailed surveys conducted early in decommissioning will quantify the locations and amounts of radioactivity waiting for a fire for re-release.

Thanks,
Dave Lochbaum
UCS

I am personally in favor of opening these lands to the public- creating a Nature Preserve with limited access to these precious lands. After they have been provided with warnings that anyone entering there is provided with the information that they may be receiving doses of residual radiation left over from the long time operation of a nuclear power plant nearby; including the information that highly radioactive spent fuel rods are stored nearby whose safety cannot be guaranteed.. And that they are taking their own health and life into their hands by being there. Also signing a liability release to that fact, prior to entering those properties. I am not in favor or "developing" the properties (ie: Cherry Canyon) to the building of residential home sites.
Thank you for this opportunity to give you my personal input on these topics. If needed, you can contact me at simonemalboeuf@gmail.com

August 26, 2018Lands

I received this comment from a community member: “Please conserve Diablo Canyon lands. If we made it a National Park, it would be a natural as well as economic boon to our Central Coast💚🌿”

August 26, 2018Lands

This flyer was prepared and distributed for the upcoming Lands meeting, by the Friends of Wild Cherry Canyon

Friends of Wild Cherry Canyongoogle.com
August 26, 2018Lands

Please make non-vehicle trails, especially for equestrians.

August 26, 2018Lands

Please allow public access on multi use, non-motorized, trails. Including equestrians. In developing the area, consider the staging requirements, and if possible, access to water to drink for the horses, as they have provided at Momtana de Oro. Thank you.

August 26, 2018Lands

I'd like to ride my horse from MdO to Avila someday.

Ride Nipomo and WCRMHC
August 26, 2018Lands

Please preserve as much land as possible for non motorized trails and. CAmping/riding:hiking. Such activities would generate revenue for the county.

August 25, 2018Lands

It would be wonderful if the land were set aside for camping, hiking, Equestrian trails. No motorized vehicles please.

August 25, 2018Lands

Preserve it all - lots of trails for horses / hiking / non-motorized vehicles, and camping. This land should be open to all SLO County residents for their outdoor enjoyment.

August 24, 2018Lands

Equestrian trails possible horse camp

Back Country Horsemen, Vaqueras del Camino, Atascadero Trail Riders, SLOCO Trail Blazers
August 24, 2018Lands

Please make open land available for horse riding and rig parking

Trail ride clubs
August 23, 2018Lands

I ask that in the plans for future use of the open lands equestrian trails and access be maintained and permitted on the Diablo Lands, including Wild Cherry Canyon.

Ride Nipomo
August 23, 2018Lands

Power generation in the form of wave, wind and solar technology, clean water generation for the local community from the desalination facility and perhaps fog and atmosphere water capture as well, make it a beacon of clean tech demonstration, education and research... put us on the map!

none
August 22, 2018Lands

Please be sure to leave the surrounding areas safe, stable, and in public domain; the archeological native Americans, the current Agricultural zoning, and the possibilities of annexing the land to State Parks or County of SLO are greater value than sellong to a private developer.
Please, please protect Wild Cherry Canyon from development, and also please be sure to have earthquake safety measures in complete preparation & ready for future catastrophes.

Friends of Wild Cherry Canyon
August 22, 2018Lands

arrange for trails for equestrians through out this land. Hikers and Bikers also. Keep off road vehicles off keep it nice.

Ride Nipomo, West Coast Rocky Mountain Horse Club. Rotary Club of Nipomo,
August 22, 2018Lands

would like to see a non motorized multi use trail. Possible camping. Horse riding

Ride Nipomo
August 22, 2018Lands

Use the open space for horse trails. Many areas to ride have been developed and growing up here my whole life, I’ve always had plenty of places to spend outside. Our little town isn’t so little any more and our wide open spaces are shrinking. It sure would be nice to have more room to explore the outdoors!

August 22, 2018Lands

I received this comment from a member of the public: “National Park please!”

August 22, 2018Lands

I would love to be able to ride my horse from Montana De Oro to Avila some day.

SLO County horse connection
August 22, 2018Lands

I would like to see a large part of the land used for public access and conservation. This Includes non motorized trails and camping.

None
August 22, 2018Lands

I would like to be able to ride my horse from MdO to Avalia

Ride Nipomo
August 22, 2018Lands

I would like to be able to ride my horse from MdO to Avalia

Ride Nipomo
August 22, 2018Lands

New trails and hikes would be wonderful, especially if I can ride my horse on them! Exercise for both me and my animals.

August 22, 2018Lands

Would love to ride my horse in this area. Also would like to ride my horse from MDO to Availa some day.

Ride Nipomo, SLO Post
August 22, 2018Lands

Please consider maintaining the land for public use. I am a mountain biker, hiker and equestrian so I would support trails for non vehicular use. Thank you

Ride Nipomo
August 22, 2018Lands

I highly support the use of multi-use lands and trails for non-motorized recreational use. Equestrians, especially, are being squeezed out of more and more places to safely ride.

August 22, 2018Lands

The attached email was submitted to fellow Engagement Panel members on August 22, 2018

google.com
August 22, 2018Lands

Please preserve as much open land as possible for multiuse trails in Cherry Canyon. We would like hike and ride our horses on this beautiful land.

Ride Nipomo Trail Alliance
August 22, 2018Lands

Good morning. I am a member of several equestrian groups in the area. I am also on the beach patrol; for the State of California in the Oceano Dunes area. I would like to encourage you to keep the Diablo property for public use and recreation purposes. It would be perfect for multi-purpose trails, camping, hiking, etc. There are thousands of visitors who come here numerous times during the year. Even if there is a small charge for usage of the land, it would certainly bring in a good deal of money for the county.

Thundering Hooves of the Central Coast, West Coast Rocky Mountain Horse Club, MVP Oceano Dunes, Longriders, Ride Nipomo
August 22, 2018Lands

I would love to see multi use trails and horse access. ❤️

August 22, 2018Lands

I would really like the area to be made available for non motorized use, such as horse riding, bicycles and camping use.

August 22, 2018Lands

I would like to be able to ride my horse from Montana de Oro to Avila someday. It would be nice if the land is managed by the Nature Conservancy or Parks and Recreation to preserve this natural resource for public use and enjoyment. Additionally, there are volunteer organizations such as equestrian and mountain bike alliances that help maintain public trails in our area.

August 22, 2018Lands

I am an equestrian and want to have public, non-motorized trails on the land surrounding Diablo Canyon and Wild Cherry Canyon all the way to Montana de Oro State Park. This is a great opportunity to provide the public with much needed recreational use of previously unavailable land. There are many public places for bicyclists and hikers in SLO county but few for equestrians. Multi use trails would be good for everyone. I also think a horse camp would be a wonderful addition and the local equestrian community would pitch in to make that a reality.

SLOPOST secretary and board member, President West Coast Rocky Mountain Horse Club; Back Country Horsemen member
August 22, 2018Lands

Would hope any plans allow for horseback use and access to the property involved.

August 21, 2018Lands

The community will be most impacted by Diablo’s closing, so give something back and provide more open space and public trails through these lands.

August 21, 2018Lands

From Tom Luster of the California Coastal Commission:

“This is another follow-up for you regarding the questions I got on Friday about the Coastal Trail routes through the Diablo Lands and in/near Avila Beach. For the Diablo Lands, we apparently don’t have any documents that show specific recommended routes, but the preference for the coastal route would be similar to the routes north and south of the facility – i.e., relatively close (+/- 25’) to the bluff edge. It will likely take a site visit to determine what route might be feasible through the facility site itself, though again with a preference to be on the coastal side of the facility.

Regarding access near Avila, I understand there is a long-proposed “promenade” between Avila and Port San Luis that would run along the coastal side of the road and would be an extension of the Bob Jones Trail south of Avila. It, too, is still in the conceptual stage, though someone at the County may have more information about its status.

Hope this helps for now,

Tom L.”

California Coastal Commission
August 20, 2018Lands

Attached is the REVISED resolution by the Sierra Club, urging the conservation of all of the Diablo Lands, including Wild Cherry Canyon.

Sierra Clubgoogle.com
August 20, 2018Lands

Attached is the REVISED Coastal Commission letter dated August 20, 2018 from the California Coastal Commission regarding the Diablo Lands.

California Coastal Commissiongoogle.com
August 20, 2018Lands

I am concerned about (including conservation and public access such as a 20-mile coastal trail through the Irish Hills) the Diablo Lands, including Wild Cherry Canyon. I would like you to consider setting the 12,000 acres that surround the plant and also the 2400 acre Wild Cherry Canyon property for resource protection and public access. This has been a focus of conservation efforts for many years.

August 20, 2018Lands

Multiple multi-use trails similar in design and public use accessibility as the Montana de Oro State Park.

Atascadero Horsemen
August 20, 2018Lands

I spoke to two members of the audience at the Lands workshops, who suggested that PG&E might consider offering the north/Field Ranch - since it was purchased with ratepayer dollars - as mitigation for PG&E’s request to the PUC for approx. $2 billion more in the December filing to find decommissioning activities.

August 20, 2018Lands

I talked to an Avila resident at the first Lands workshop and he was very interested in the two quotes that PG&E had made years ago in support of the Dream Initiative (Measure A). He thought that the utility should live up to those words and honor the public vote, and conserve all of the Diablo Lands, including Wild Cherry Canyon.

August 19, 2018Lands

consider adding the Pt. Buchon trail to the state park system as part of Montana de Oro SP

DateDecommissioning TopicComment / Suggestion:Group Affiliation, if any (Optional)Link to Web Page or Online FileUploaded File 1Uploaded File 2
Scroll to Top